23 July 2018 · Xavier Meeuwissen
This book targets industrial valve users (process engineer, maintenance engineer, plant designer). It concentrates on the valve selection for typical liquid or gas application, i.e. 1 to 24” for low to moderate duty.
This book serves also to a great reference for your general question about valves. It is well structured and all information is accessible via the table of content. The author starts with the fluid motions and the valve functionality. The content also is easy to read without any prior valve knowledge.
It introduces the most common types of valves, mainly off-the-shelve valves. Furthermore, it guides the reader through the characteristics and benefits of each type. With this overview, you can select the correct type of valve to integrate into your standard application. In regards to the accessories (actuator, instrumentation, feature), the emphasis is on the pneumatic type. The manual and electric actuation are only introduced. Finally, the author reviews a few interesting valve problems; like cavitation, water-hammer effect, and noise attenuation.
My main critic relates to the lack of consideration of considering the complete life-cycle of the valve. The author restricts the selection on the valve design and sizing. The valve accessibility, maintenance (lubrication) or reconditioning (spare part) are not covered. According to Brian Nesbitt, almost three-quarters of the cost is expended on maintenance and repairs!
Furthermore, numerous current valve application required a positive isolation. Subjects, like man-safe valve, drain, vent, double block and bleed, would have been useful for the target audience.
Finally, the author concentrates on off-the-shelve valves with most illustrations from Valtek-Flowserve. The subjects covered stays general like Wikipedia article without much of personality. Short real-life examples scattered throughout the book could have given more depth and help assimilate the content. It also fails to introduce many special valves or features
- special types of valves, like man-safe valve, material valve, slurry valve or pressure relief valve.
- cryogenic/ high-temperature application.
- special accessories like mechanical locking device, position indicator or automatic lubrication.
- hydraulic actuation for heavy duty valve.
For instance, the author describes the ASME pressure classes used for standard valves. But it does not detail the different pressurized situation involved into the valve selection (open, closed, stroking, absolute, relative, differential). It restricts also from all the benefits of specially engineered design.
In conclusion, this books misses a few chapters to be a comprehensive handbook for valve users and it doesn’t cover the design of industrial valves. But it is a great introduction to the most used industrial valves. It introduces most general questions about valve selections. The book will not replace the expert from your valve manufacturer/distributor.
